April 29 , 2008 | Issue 58
 

“It’s not what you know, it’s who you know.”  Although the validity of that statement can be contested, there’s no doubt that who a person knows can definitely be a factor in their overall success.  In this issue of The Animal Science Monitor, we’re going to explore the topic of who you know—or who your candidates know—in other words, the topic of references.  As always, we hope that you enjoy this issue of The ASM.  And in case you were wondering, we’re glad to know you.

Dan and Don



> Using Reference Checks Effectively
> Managing—and Investing in—Your References



Using Reference Checks Effectively

(By Dan Simmons)

Some companies don't bother checking references because they believe "everyone has friends and those are the people you'll be speaking with," while others conduct as many as 10, yes 10, reference calls in some cases.  It has been my experience that 3-4 reference checks can provide a great deal of insightful information if you’ve prepared the correct questions.  These questions should be constructed to help determine if you should hire the person for this particular job, if they possess promotion potential, and how you can coach them to meet that potential.

First pick who

Choosing the right people to speak with is important, because yes, everyone does have friends.  Your goal is to collect unbiased information from people who know.  Choose previous supervisors, mentors, peers, customers (internal or external), and if appropriate, subordinates.  Previous and current supervisors are preferred, but make certain you are not putting this person's job in jeopardy by calling their boss unless you have their permission and expect that you will make an acceptable offer if the reference goes well.  This is where previous supervisors and mentors come in.  These people know the candidate well enough to provide value.

Cover the basics early in the call

People providing references will want to say good things, so ask questions they can be happy answering first.  Ask about how and when they and the candidate worked together and the candidate’s strengths and weaknesses.  Talk about skills and talents.  Then explore why the candidate left or is considering leaving their current job.  Then move into important areas such as character and integrity.

Digging deeper

The reason to do reference work late in the interview process is to learn what you couldn't find out through interviewing or assessments.  Ask questions about whatever concerns the hiring team.  If you're concerned about the candidate’s ability to interact well with a team, dig in with questions about this.  Be clear that you want to make this a win-win situation and that you’ve found many good traits in this person, but you have these concerns.  The person will often open up and address these specific concerns and put your concerns to rest, or they’ll keep you from making a mistake. 

Think about the future

If, after digging into the areas of concern, you think this person is a good candidate, ask about their leadership style and/or leadership potential.  As this person has more experience with the candidate than you, ask how they would recommend coaching this individual.  These tips should be relayed to everyone who is going to help the candidate become acclimated, and particularly to the direct supervisor.  Some people learn best with specific instruction; others need a general direction and a long leash.  Learn how to coach this person for success.

Disclaimers, legal items and non-responses

There are laws governing reference checks.  These include having the person's written permission to check references.  Talk with your HR department to make certain you are following the federal and state laws that govern your area.  In addition, many companies, particularly the Fortune 500, will only provide dates of employment, title, and salary information, and they will want to see the written authorization to release this information.  One way around this is to contact the people he worked with and ask for a personal reference, not a professional reference.  Slant the questions toward personality traits and try to weave in other questions.  This will sometimes work, particularly if you call the person at their home number during the evening.

The last word

Reference checks should be one of the deciding factors in the hiring process, not the only one.  There are people who may hold a grudge against a fine person who was a great asset to a company, and subsequently, they’ll give a lousy reference.  Beware of speaking with these people.  This is why conducting 3-4 references will help.  Balance what you hear, and make more calls if necessary.  Weigh the most recent and closer working relationships more heavily than others.  If, after you have done your due diligence, you still have doubts, pass on the candidate.  Better to lose a good hire than hire a loser.

If you have any questions about this topic—or any other regarding recruiting, rewarding, or retaining top talent—contact me at dan@consearch.com.



 

Managing—and Investing in—Your References
(By Don Hunter)

When it comes to your references, there’s not much room for error.

What do I mean by that?  Simply that gaps in information or lapses in communication can prove to be costly.  That’s why it’s crucial that you pay the proper amount of attention to your references, much in the same way that you pay attention to your resume.  In essence, you shouldn’t be just maintaining a list of references, you should be managing your references.

Gathering and mining the data
Even if you’re still in school and have yet to graduate, you should already have a list of references.  You should have three at the absolute minimum and five to seven, if possible.  These are all people who must have a comprehensive knowledge of your abilities and work ethic and also people who have granted permission for you to list them as a reference.  References fall into three distinct categories—employer, academic, and personal.  Make sure that you categorize each of your references in the correct fashion.

It’s advisable that not only should you meticulously document your references—updating information like physical address, email address, and phone numbers on a consistent basis—you should also track your communication with them.  When did you last speak with them?  What did you speak with them about?  When was the last time they provided a reference for you?

This type of information is for your personal, internal use.  However, for the purposes of your job search, you’ll need to track other information, as well.  This information includes the person’s full name, job title, and company name.  (If one of your top references switches jobs, you need to know about it.)  All of this data, in addition to the appropriate contact information, will need to be provided to a prospective employer during the interview process.  Depending upon the company, it might be included with your resume or on a piece of paper separate from the resume.

From managing to investing
Okay, so now you’re preparing to interview for a new position.  What should you do?  Contact your references and let them know they might be getting a call in the near future or within a specific timeframe?  Yes, but that’s only part of it.  You also need to provide the references with your most recent resume, the name of the company with which you’re interviewing, and a copy of the job description.  With this information, your references will be better able to tie your skills and abilities to the position for which you’re applying.

You can even go one step further by giving your references gentle direction, letting them know what they might be asked about.  Through your prior contact with the hiring authority or other officials, perhaps you have an idea of what’s most important to the company in its quest to fill the position.  You could ask certain references to touch upon key points related to the company’s most pressing needs.  This type of targeted reference could make a big difference.

In addition, make certain to thank your references often.  In fact, thank them every time you speak with them, and if possible, take them out for coffee if the opportunity arises.   After all, they’re providing a valuable service for you.  They might just be one of the deciding factors in whether or not you land the job of your dreams.

Follow-up is extremely important, as well.  Regardless of the eventual outcome, contact all of your references and let them know what happened.  This will keep them vested in the process and improve the odds that they’ll provide an excellent reference for you going forward.  And of course, let them know that you’ll be calling them in the future and that they should let you know if anything changes in their employment or with their contact information.

In the final analysis, you shouldn’t be simply maintaining your references or even managing them, but investing in them.  I’m talking about an investment of time and energy.  This simple shift in mindset will help you to approach your references in the proper fashion, so that you can maximize the effectiveness that these references have on your job search and ultimately, on your career.

If you have any questions about this topic, please send me an email at brg@charterinternet.com.  And if you’re currently engaged in a job search or are interested in advancing the scope of your career, be sure to send me your resume.  I’d be happy to discuss your career goals and ambitions, including ways in which I can help you to achieve them.  Any exchange of information, including resumes, will be kept in total confidence and handled in a discreet fashion.

 

HOT JOBS
Brought to you by
AnimalScienceJobs.com

To Search all of our Jobs, click the following links:

Poultry Jobs

Dairy Jobs
Equine Jobs
Swine Jobs
Companion Animal Jobs

Plant Manager
Ohio Valley

Energetic, Exp'd Feed Mill Plant Mgr needed for busy operation in Ohio Valley.
Room for advancement and competitive $$.
For more details contact Dan Simmons dan@consearch.com

Director of Purchasing
Upper Mid-west

Major company seeks top-level purchasing executive to lead team of 8.  Compensation = Experience
For more details contact Dan Simmons dan@consearch.com

Director of Nutrition
Upper Mid-west

Regional feed company seeks exp'd Ph.D. to lead technical services and product development.  Dairy exp. req'd.
For more details contact Don Hunter brg@charterinternet.com

Livestock Sales Rep
Iowa

Major Feed Company seeks livestock generalist to take over a territory open due to retirement.  Develop & support dealers.
For more details contact Don Hunter brg@charterinternet.co

Feed Formulator
Ohio

Feed company seeks experienced ration balancer to work with a variety of species.  Exc. Benefits, growing company.
For more details contact Dan Simmons dan@consearch.com

Dairy Nutritionist
Pennsylvania

Regional Feed Company seeks sales consultant to further develop a territory in central PA.  Excellent $$ and great products.

For more details contact Dan Simmons dan@consearch.com

Large Herd Specialist

Location - Panhandle, TX
Direct to Farm Nutritionist in the hottest growth spot in the dairy industry. Compensation $$$!!!
For more details contact Dan Simmons dan@consearch.com
 

Territory Manager

Location - Western NY
Cover an established territory selling animal health and silage products to dealers/distributors and provide sales support to producers.
For more details contact Don Hunter brg@charterinternet.com
 
Dairy Nutrition Consultant

Location - Madison, WI
Experienced Nutritionist with MS degree to develop territory in south central WI for mineral company
For more details contact Don Hunter brg@charterinternet.com
 
Farm Store Managers

Location - Mid Atlantic and Southeast
Manage multi-million dollar feed and farm stores.  Must have relevant experience.  Exc Benefits, Salary & Bonus
For more details contact Dan Simmons dan@consearch.com

Sow Production Manager

Location - Ohio
Manage 5 sow units for growing swine management company
For more details contact Dan Simmons dan@consearch.com